Reviews by Category: Mystery

Teen Review
A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder by Holly Jackson

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder

By Holly Jackson
Star Rating
★★★★★

Rated by
Saanvi M.
Jan 2, 2024

Pippa-Fitz Amobi, a senior in high school, must complete a research project on a topic of her choice; something she is passionate about. She looks into a past murder case of a girl named Andie Bell. Sal Singh, along with Andie, had been found dead in the forest. According to clues at the scene of the crime, all hints pointed to one scenario: Sal killed Andie (who is also his girlfriend) and killed himself afterwards as a result of guilt and regret. Despite the case being declared closed by the authorities, Pip finds it hard to believe. It seemed a bit too obvious.

Teen Review
The Hawthorne Legacy book cover

The Hawthorne Legacy

By Jennifer Lynn Barnes
Star Rating
★★★★

Rated by
Earvin C
Dec 29, 2023

In The Hawthorne Legacy, main character Avery Grambs continues to search for the answers within billionaire Tobias Hawthorne’s puzzles and mysteries embedded within the walls of the Hawthrone Estate. Her mother’s game of “secrets” continues to replay in her mind as she struggles to differentiate her manipulative illusions with reality, all while debating her love situation with the Hawthrone brothers. 

Teen Review
Shade Me book cover

Shade Me

By Jennifer Brown
Star Rating
★★★★

Rated by
Kadelyn B.
Dec 29, 2023

Shade Me written by Jennifer Brown is a YA fiction about crime, mystery, and murder. The main character Nikki Kill has lived her whole life with a condition called synesthesia. This causes her senses to overlap and gives her the ability to see colors when presented with emotions, information, and various other experiences. One day she receives a mysterious call from the hospital asking for her help to identify a young woman in critical condition and Nikki’s number is the only one listed in this Jane Doe’s phone.

Teen Review
The Inheritance Games book cover

The Inheritance Games

By Jennifer Lynn Barnes
Star Rating
★★★

Rated by
Anonymous
Dec 29, 2023

Avery Grambs is an average 17-year-old girl from Connecticut. She finds out that she has inherited 46 billion dollars from Tobias Hawthorne, a very wealthy man. However, Tobias is a total stranger to Avery. With no record of being connected to this man at all, she becomes suspicious of whether or not this is real. There is one condition that comes along with the money-she is required to live in Tobias Hawthorne’s mansion along with his living family. Avery must adjust to her new situation while also trying to uncover the secrets that come along with it.

Teen Review
One Of Us Is Lying

One Of Us Is Lying

By Karen M. McManus
Star Rating
★★★★★

Rated by
Margo H.
Dec 22, 2023

One Of Us Is Lying, a fictional mystery by Karen M. McManus covers what seems to be the lives of 5 normal high school students in detention class until one of them dies. When Simon suddenly passes it makes Bronwyn, Addy, Nate, and Cooper the four main suspects. Throughout the book, the readers see views from all four students and their suspicions about what happened. Was it Bronwyn? Was it Addy? Was it Nate? Was it Cooper? Did they all do it together? Did none of them do it?

Teen Review
Dark Places

Dark Places

By Gillian Flynn
Star Rating
★★★★

Rated by
Anonymous
Dec 22, 2023

At the age of seven, Libby's mother and two older sisters were murdered in what seemed to be a satanic bloodbath orchestrated by her older brother Ben. Libby managed to escape and played a crucial role in getting him incarcerated, thanks to a coercive interrogation tactic. Fast forward twenty-five years, and Libby is a struggling, penniless kleptomaniac harboring resentment towards the world. Her life takes a turn when she's approached by a group fascinated by violent crimes, engaging in activities like studying them, trading memorabilia, and constructing alternative horror scenarios.

Teen Review
Five Total Strangers

Five Total Strangers

By Natalie D. Richards
Star Rating
★★★★

Rated by
t.willow
Dec 22, 2023

Five Total Strangers by Natalie D. Richards is a thrilling fictional tale about 5 different strangers, all of whom are stuck at the airport with their flights canceled, due to a blizzard. Wanting to get home for the holidays, they all decide to rent a car and drop people off along the way to each of their routes. Riding with strangers isn’t too bad if you semi-trust them, that is, until secretly, one person in the car starts sabotaging the ride.

Teen Review
Daisy Darker

Daisy Darker

By Alice Feeney
Star Rating
★★★★★

Rated by
t.willow
Dec 22, 2023

Daisy Darker by Alice Feeney is a mystery thriller that dives deep into the story of the main protagonist, Daisy Darker. Her whole family has not all been together for years until they finally come together for her grandmother’s 81st birthday. Daisy’s grandmother announces her will to everyone, the night goes on, and then shortly after midnight, she is found dead, with a poem written on the wall behind her body. Suddenly everyone is awake, and they each start dying off, one by one.

Teen Review
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time

The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time

By Mark Haddon
Star Rating
★★★★★

Rated by
Anonymous
Dec 12, 2023

Summary: The story starts with 15-year-old Christopher John Francis Boone, who discovers the body of Wellington, his neighbor Mrs. Shears’ dog, dead on their lawn. Christopher decides to investigate the context of the murder and uncover the culprit. Throughout his investigation, we learn more about Christopher’s life, personality, and defining characteristics. Although it is not explicitly stated, it is highly suggested he has a form of autism. These traits aid and hinder him in his investigation.

Teen Review
The Third Twin

The Third Twin

By Cynthia James Omololu
Star Rating
★★★

Rated by
Hannah K.
Dec 12, 2023

The Third Twin by Cynthia James Omololu is a mystery thriller about 2 identical twins who have to figure out why their dates keep turning up dead. Ava and Alexa (Lexi) are seniors who are part of a relatively wealthy family in California. When they were younger, the twins made up an imaginary third twin named Alicia who was blamed for their naughty actions. However, when they got older Ava and Lexi decided to date and dump boys with the persona of Alicia.

Browse by Tag